NEW RENTAL: MAGICAL SHELTER ISLAND RETREAT | House in Shelter Island

10.0 (4 Reviews) |   5 Bedrooms  6 Bathrooms  12 Guests
Shelter Island Heights House | NEW RENTAL: MAGICAL SHELTER ISLAND RETREAT

5 Bedroom House in Shelter Island Heights, Shelter Island

Take the singular Shelter Island drive over Ram Island’s renowned causeways to this meticulously renovated and expanded 1933 charming, waterview home of stone and cedar on the most sought after Big Ram Island block. 5 bedrooms, 6 bathrooms and large living spaces flow seamlessly with the outdoors, thanks to the expansive covered porches off the living room and large patio connecting the pool and hot tub with the kitchen and family room. Every detail was considered in the home in terms of beauty, function and experience. It’s owner, a veteran in the home decor industry, designed all fabrics and wallpapers and spec’ed every detail. The house sits on 1.4 acres of land, with a large lawn, wraparound porches to take in the views and space for everyone to enjoy, lounge, play or explore.
Bask in the sparkling sunshine on Coecles Harbor, take in the sunset from the two hanging porch-beds, or waterview-dine on the covered veranda. Swim in the heated pool, relax in the grotto-like hot tub or infrared sauna, or paddleboard, sail, fish or kayak just out your front door off the small beach that’s shared by the neighbors. Paddleboards stay parked here, and morning dips are mandatory in this idyllic spot. Off the beach, 37 Tuthill has a boat mooring, useable by renters. A short walk to the end of Tuthill Drive brings you to Reel Point, a sand peninsula lined with osprey nest platforms and blankets of seashells.
Coecles Harbor is a protected deep-water harbor that faces Mashomack Preserve, with over 2000 acres of interlacing tidal creeks, woodlands and freshwater marshes, easily accessible by paddleboard off our beach. The harbor is prized by sailors, swimmers and fishermen for its pristine, protected waters. The island enjoys a similar sense of peace and tranquility.
Perfect for everything from a relaxing couples getaway to a fun-filled family or friends gathering, this is fantastically special home designed for making cherished memories, in a magical corner of the world.

NEW RENTAL: MAGICAL SHELTER ISLAND RETREAT is located in Shelter Island Heights. NEW RENTAL: MAGICAL SHELTER ISLAND RETREAT provides accommodation, featuring Fireplace/Heating, Child Friendly, Hot Tub, among other amenities. This House features Fireplace/Heating, Child Friendly, Hot Tub, to make your stay a comfortable one.

NEW RENTAL: MAGICAL SHELTER ISLAND RETREAT has 5 Bedrooms , 6 Bathrooms, and max occupancy of 12 people. The minimum rental for this property is 1 nights, but this can change depending on the season you plan on staying. Previous guests have given good rated it, and VRBO labeled it a top-rated House because of the excellent services rendered by the owner or manager of this House, and has consistently provided great experiences for their guests. Most families or guests that use it recommend it to their friends and some of them are repeat guests. House has a friendly neighborhood, and the Shelter Island Heights has interesting places to visit. If you want to learn more about the House in Shelter Island Heights, such as places to visit and things to do nearby, you can check below to learn more.

Show more
OneKey Logos

This Property is OneKey Eligible

Earn OneKeyCash for every dollar spent on eligible vacation rentals, villas, cottages, cabins, and more when you book on Vrbo.

JOIN TODAY

Amenities

Air Conditioner
Parking
Pool
TV
View
Private Pool
Ocean View
Balcony/Terrace
Oceanfront
Security/Safety
Sports/Activities
Bedding/Linens
Wellness Facilities
Spa
Fireplace/Heating
Guest Services
Entertainment
Barbecue/Outdoor Cooking
Child Friendly
Hot Tub
Internet
Kitchen
Laundry

Facility Overview

Air Conditioner
  • Air conditioning
  • Heating
Bathrooms
  • Towels provided
  • Bathtub or shower
  • Shampoo
  • Soap
  • 6 bathrooms
  • Toilet paper
  • Hair dryer
Bedroom
  • Bed sheets provided
  • 5 bedrooms
  • Dining table
  • Living room
  • Fireplace
Kitchen
  • Oven
  • Stovetop
  • Cookware/dishes/utensils
  • Toaster
  • Microwave
  • Coffee/tea maker
  • Spices
  • Dishwasher
  • Refrigerator
Laundry
  • Washing machine and dryer
  • Laundry facilities
Ocean view
  • Beach sun loungers
  • Near the beach
  • Beach towels
Parking
  • Onsite parking
  • Onsite parking options include a garage
Pet Friendly
  • No pets allowed
Accessibility
  • If you have requests for specific accessibility needs, please contact the property using the information on the reservation confirmation received after booking.
  • Tile flooring in public areas
  • Wheelchair-accessible pool
  • 6 stairs to reach property
  • Area rugs in public areas
  • Well-lit path to entrance
  • Wheelchair-accessible path of travel
  • Smoke-free property
  • No elevators
  • Hardwood flooring in public areas
Activities
  • Fitness facilities nearby
  • Windsurfing nearby
  • Winery tours nearby
  • Sailing nearby
  • Bicycle on site
  • Water sports equipment
  • Water skiing nearby
  • Cycling nearby
  • Marina nearby
  • Wildlife and game walks nearby
  • Power boating nearby
  • Fishing nearby
Entertainment
  • Games
  • Smart TV with cable/satellite service
  • Books
  • Arcade/game room
  • Table tennis
  • Stereo
General
  • At least 80% of food locally-sourced
  • At least 80% lighting from LEDs
  • Unit size: 5730 sq ft (532 sq m)
  • Double-glazed windows
  • At least 80% organic food
  • Vegan dining options
  • French
  • English
  • Near the sea
  • On the waterfront
  • Near the bay
  • Desk
Guest Services
  • Playground
  • Children's games
  • Concierge services
  • Chef
  • Local meal delivery service
  • Housekeeping (on request)
  • Change of towels (on request)
  • Iron/ironing board
  • Change of bedsheets (on request)
  • Safe
Internet
  • Free WiFi
Outdoors
  • Balcony
  • Barbecue grill
  • Garden
  • Outdoor furniture
Security/Safety
  • First aid kit
  • Smoke detector installed (host has indicated there is a smoke detector on the property)
  • Deadbolt lock
  • Fire extinguisher
  • Carbon monoxide detector installed (host has indicated there is a carbon monoxide detector on the property)
Spa
  • Sauna
  • Private pool
  • Massages
  • Outdoor pool
  • Heated pool
  • Hot tub

Policies

Check-in
Check-in time starts at 4:00 pm minimum check-in age: 30
Check-out
Check-out before 11:00 am
Child Policy
Children are welcome.
Event Policy
Events allowed: family gatherings and birthday parties;maximum event attendees: 30
Pet Policy
Pets not allowed
Smoking Policy
Smoking is not permitted

Extra-person charges may apply and vary depending on property policy government-issued photo identification and a credit card, debit card, or cash deposit may be required at check-in for incidental charges host has indicated there is a carbon monoxide detector on the property host has indicated there is a smoke detector on the property long-term renters welcome parties and events (including family gatherings and birthday parties) are allowed on site; maximum attendees: 30 property registration number 2024-l-0018 safety features at this property include a fire extinguisher, a first aid kit, and a deadbolt lock special requests are subject to availability upon check-in and may incur additional charges; special requests cannot be guaranteed this property is managed through our partner, vrbo. you will receive an email from vrbo with a link to a vrbo account, where you can change or cancel your reservation this property uses a grey water recycling system

License number: 2024-L-0018

Reviews

Lucy H.
Jul 5, 2025 11:17:21 PM
Review Score:   10
Summary: We had a great stay here with our adult children and grandchild. The house has a good lay-out, and is beautifully designed. The kitchen is very well equipped, with lots of counterspace and a large pantry. We used both sitting rooms; one has a large table for jigsaw puzzles. The pool and hot tub were so pretty, and we ate at a table there, or on the covered porch, every night. There is a large, clean outdoor shower. We hope to be back!
See All Reviews
Check House Availability
Nightly rates from:
USD US $1,665
You will be redirected to  
Hot Deal - It has been viewed 30 times today
Not the right fit? Check out our other properties in Shelter Island Heights
Property Image From US $1,289
         

Property Image From US $211
         

9.4 (79 Reviews)
House
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Balcony/Terrace
Property Image From US $341
         

|
9.8 (71 Reviews)
Bed & Breakfast
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pet Friendly
Property Image From US $147
         

|
8.1 (16 Reviews)
Bed & Breakfast
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • View
Property Image From US $692
         

Property Image From US $343
         

10.0 (52 Reviews)
House
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pet Friendly
Property Image From US $604
         

9.6 (13 Reviews)
House
  • Air Conditioner
  • Parking
  • Pet Friendly